Replacing split lock washers on existing plant is usually a straight swap rather than a redesign. Serrated safety washers outperformed split lock, detent edged, ribbed and spring washers in Junker testing and maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles. The three things to check before ordering are the bolt grade, the hole type and the assembly torque, because the torque figure changes by around 10 per cent unless the washers are zinc plated.
Retrofit work has a different constraint set to new design. You cannot change the hole, the grade is whatever the last engineer chose, and the window to do the work is a shutdown that is already too short.
Why the upgrade is worth doing
The case for an anti-vibration washer upgrade is the test data. In Junker testing, connections secured with SCHNORR safety washers maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles, showing superior locking performance compared with split lock washers, detent edged washers, ribbed washers and spring washers, and an equivalent locking effect to a wedge-locking washer.
The mechanism is the difference. A split washer relies largely on spring pressure. A serrated safety washer secures through friction and mechanical locking together, with a closed ring form that gives high pretension without the burst open effect, and uniform axial loading that eliminates bending torques and deformation of the bolt stem.
Check one: bolt grade
Type S covers bolt sizes M1.6 to M36 in property classes up to 8.8. If the plant runs grade 10.9 fasteners, or if the joint is at the top of its preload capability, specify type VS, which is thicker for higher pre-tensioning loads and fits M5 to M30.
Check two: the hole
Existing plant is full of slots and elongated holes, especially on adjustable mountings and machine feet. Type VS is applicable to elongated holes, and on a slot it needs around 25 per cent lower initial torque than an unsecured bolt, with good securing effect and only minor damage to the bolt head. Clearance holes work with safety washers on both sides of the joint, and counterbores are a designed-for case.
Check three: the torque figure in the work instruction
This is the step most often missed on a retrofit locking washers job. To reach the same initial force with a type S or type VS washer, the initial torque has to be about 10 per cent larger than for a bolt without a securing device. Zinc plated washers do not need that increase, because the additional friction from the serrated surface is offset by the lubricating effect of the coating. Update the work instruction at the same time as the parts list, or the joint goes back together undertightened.
Dimensions and fit
On serrated washer dimensions, the outer diameter is matched to the head diameter of pan head and socket head cap screws, and type S and type VS share the same inside and outside diameters, differing in thickness. So a VS substitution changes the stack height slightly, which matters where thread engagement is already marginal.
Finish, and one thing not to do
A black surface gives the best securing effect, and zinc coated washers secure a joint perfectly well provided the bolt is tightened with the appropriate initial force. Whatever finish you choose, do not fit the new safety washer on top of the plain washer that was already in the joint. A plain washer underneath removes the mechanical locking half of the effect, and it is the single most common error on retrofit work.
- In Junker testing, SCHNORR safety washers maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles, with superior locking performance to split lock, detent edged, ribbed and spring washers and an equivalent effect to a wedge-locking washer.
- Serrated safety washers secure joints through friction and mechanical locking, with a closed ring form that avoids the burst open effect.
- Uniform axial loading eliminates bending torques and deformation of the bolt stem.
- Type S covers M1.6 to M36 up to property class 8.8. Type VS is thicker, suits grade 10.9 and fits M5 to M30.
- Type VS is applicable to elongated holes and requires about 25 per cent lower initial torque than an unsecured bolt on a slot.
- Initial torque should be about 10 per cent higher with type S or VS washers, except zinc plated versions, which need no increase.
- Type S and type VS share the same inside and outside diameters and differ in thickness.
- A plain washer must not be fitted under a serrated safety washer.
Frequently asked questions
Can I replace split lock washers with serrated safety washers on existing equipment?
Usually yes. Check the bolt grade to choose type S or type VS, check the hole type, and update the assembly torque, which should be about 10 per cent higher unless the washers are zinc plated.
Are serrated safety washers better than spring washers?
In Junker testing, SCHNORR safety washers showed superior locking performance compared with split lock, detent edged, ribbed and spring washers, and maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles.
Which washer do I use on an adjustable mounting with slots?
Type VS. It is applicable to elongated holes and needs around 25 per cent lower initial torque than an unsecured bolt, with only minor bolt head damage.
Do type S and type VS have the same dimensions?
The inside and outside diameters and the serrations are the same. Type VS is thicker to accommodate higher pre-tensioning loads.
Can I keep the existing plain washer in the joint?
No. A plain washer under a serrated safety washer removes the mechanical locking part of the securing effect. Fit the safety washer directly against the clamped surfaces.