When a bolted joint keeps coming loose, the cause is nearly always one of five things: the bolt was never tightened to full preload, the locking element cannot resist transverse slip, the washer was assembled incorrectly, the bearing surface is too hard for the serrations to bite, or the wrong washer type was specified for the hole. Check them in that order, because the first one is the most common and the cheapest to fix.
Reliability teams tend to inherit these joints rather than design them. The following order is deliberately cheapest first, so you are not sourcing new parts before you have ruled out the free explanations.
1. Preload, before anything else
Start with a bolt preload check. Tests show that when bolts are tightened to only 75 per cent of the required initial force, results were poor and a proportion of joints came loose, and the effect was more pronounced again at 50 per cent. Tighten to 100 per cent of the initial force corresponding to the minimum required bolt tension.
Watch for the specification error that causes this quietly: with a type S or type VS safety washer, the initial torque should be around 10 per cent higher than for a bolt with no securing device. If a torque figure was carried over from an unsecured joint, the joint is being undertightened by design. Zinc plated washers are the exception and need no increase, because the coating offsets the added friction from the serrations.
2. The locking element itself
Not all locking devices behave the same under transverse movement. In Junker testing, joints secured with SCHNORR safety washers maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles, with locking performance superior to split lock washers, detent edged washers, ribbed washers and spring washers, and equivalent to a wedge-locking washer. If the joint is running a split or spring washer and cycling constantly, the element is the likely cause.
3. Assembly errors
Three safety washer assembly mistakes account for most of the rest, and all are visible on strip down:
- Washers stacked on top of each other, so the serrations bite into another washer instead of the joint.
- A plain washer fitted underneath, which removes the mechanical locking half of the effect.
- The washer fitted upside down, which changes how the load is carried.
Correct practice is a single washer, directly against the clamped surfaces, tightened to full preload. Safety washers can be used on clearance holes when there is a washer on both sides, and are designed for use in counterbores.
4. Surface hardness
As the hardness of the base surface increases, the biting effect of the serration decreases, and securing performance follows it directly. SCHNORR safety washers are 39 to 45 HRC (380 to 450 HV30), so against a hardened surface the recommendation is the high duty type VS. A joint that fails only where it meets a hardened plate is telling you exactly this.
5. Wrong washer for the hole
On slots and elongated holes, an unsecured bolt tightened fully does not necessarily loosen, but the bolt head is damaged considerably and a high initial torque is needed. With a type VS washer the required initial torque is about 25 per cent lower, the securing effect is good and head damage is minor. Type VS is the specification for elongated holes.
What to do with the parts you remove
The washers may be reusable. When a joint secured with SCHNORR safety washers is undone and retightened, the securing effect does not diminish, and they can be used two or more times without restriction. That is worth knowing on a shutdown where the parts store is closed.
And about that retorque interval
A recurring retorque is a workaround, not a maintenance strategy. If a joint is on a retorque schedule, the practical fix is to correct the preload specification and the locking element once, then take the interval out of the plan.
- Bolts tightened to only 75 per cent of the required initial force gave poor results, with a proportion of joints coming loose. The effect was more pronounced at 50 per cent.
- With type S and type VS safety washers, initial torque should be about 10 per cent higher than for a bolt with no securing device. Zinc plated washers need no increase.
- In Junker testing, SCHNORR safety washers maintained pretension force after 2,000 cycles and outperformed split lock, detent edged, ribbed and spring washers.
- Incorrect assemblies include stacked washers, a plain washer underneath, and a washer fitted upside down.
- Increasing hardness of the base surface reduces the biting effect of the serration. Washer hardness is 39 to 45 HRC (380 to 450 HV30) and type VS is recommended against hardened surfaces.
- On slots, type VS needs about 25 per cent lower initial torque than an unsecured bolt and causes only minor bolt head damage.
- SCHNORR safety washers can be reused two or more times without loss of securing effect.
Frequently asked questions
What should I check first on a joint that keeps coming loose?
The preload. Bolts tightened to only 75 per cent of the required initial force gave poor results in testing, and the effect was worse at 50 per cent. Tighten to 100 per cent of the initial force for the minimum required bolt tension.
Does a safety washer change the torque figure on the drawing?
Yes. With type S and type VS washers the initial torque should be around 10 per cent higher than for an unsecured bolt. Zinc plated washers are the exception and need no increase.
Are split lock washers and spring washers effective under vibration?
Junker testing showed SCHNORR safety washers to have superior locking performance compared with split lock washers, detent edged washers, ribbed washers and spring washers.
Why does a joint against a hardened surface still loosen?
Because the serration bites less as base surface hardness increases, and securing performance follows that bite. The high duty type VS washer is recommended against hardened surfaces.
Can I reuse safety washers after a strip down?
Yes. The securing effect does not diminish when a joint is undone and retightened, and the washers can be used two or more times without restriction.